Jump to content
  • Sign in to follow this  

    The Impossible Repair


    PeteMitchell

    It’s that time of the year when enforced hibernation makes many of us think about repairing some of the previous season’s damage.  Having had more than my fair share of dramas over the years, I have come to realise that more often than not, what seemed like a total right off at the time is with care, repairable.   Every disaster is different and not all moulded models are the same, but here is what I did to rebuild a wing tip.

    The model is an Electra F5J 3.7 mtr thermal soarer.  It’s  construction is the usual hollow moulded epoxy/ carbon/foam/glass sandwich, and is of a fairly light weight.  The tip in question was almost totally destroyed in the arrival when my radio link failed, which was traced to a faulty Lipo  The model rolled inverted and quickly disappeared behind trees about ¾ mile from my flying field. I was fortunate that apart from the fuselage tail boom being broken, this was the only significant damage.

    To start I cut away as much of the remaining damage as was needed to enable me to decide if a repair could be done. This photo shows my first attempt to piece the bottom surface together with scraps of thin carbon. This did not really work.

    impossible-repair06.thumb.jpg.32c8b51716

    As the main spar and the aileron spar had to be replaced I decided the best repair would be a ‘traditional’ balsa rebuild, but with carbon reinforcement. I started by making a paper template from the other good undamaged tip. The template idea was also dropped as the work progressed.

    impossible-repair08.thumb.jpg.dc61b85bd9

    As the repair progressed, the missing moulded surfaces were replaced with balsa sheet and I decided to make the tip from foam. I thought this was the only way I could reproduce all the curves. I cut a rough shape from blue foam and epoxied it, with carbon pins, to the rebuilt tip.

    impossible-repair07.thumb.jpg.65d0da65fe

    This shows the underside as I start to sand the repaired area, and foam tip, to shape.

    impossible-repair02.thumb.jpg.5eae594284

    Once the repair had been sanded to an overall smooth finish I wanted to complete the repair without adding any more weight than was unavoidable. I thought that to try to replicate the models colour and finish was a waste of effort and decided to use Textreem spread tow carbon. This is the material used in many of the lightest thermal soarer’s.  

    I coated the surface of the repair with wing skinning epoxy and laid the cloth on to it. The epoxy soaked through the cloth and I removed as much as I could by much blotting with kitchen roll paper. Once I had the epoxy evenly spread through the cloth and it all looked ‘dry’ I covered the completed area with  a thickish polythene cut from a rubble sack. I then carefully pressed this down all over onto the carbon with fingers and the edge of a credit card. Once again the epoxy that remained came through the cloth to the surface.

    To finish off I covered the job with as many magazines and weight as I could balance on the work bench and left it overnight to cure.  The picture shows the underside after sanding and trimming.

    impossible-repair05.thumb.jpg.0331f628b9

    I covered the underside first because the tip needed to be strong enough to allow the top surface to be sanded to its final shape. Once this was done the same process was followed which can be seen in these last two photos.

    impossible-repair03.thumb.jpg.8b7566f835

    The model had this repair plus a smaller one on the other tip and to the fuselage boom. The total gain in weight is approx. 40g which I thought was pretty good. The repaired tip is approx 25g heavier than the other, but as far as I could see it did not show in flight.

    impossible-repair04.thumb.jpg.d6fa064d58

    If you are in a similar situation, I hope these few words will help you make a start on that ‘impossible’ repair.

    Peter Mitchell

     

     

    • Like 1
    Sign in to follow this  


    User Feedback

    Recommended Comments

    There are no comments to display.


  •  

  •  

  • Our picks

    • by Sydney Lenssen, July 2018

      Brian Austin has been co-opted by the BARCS Executive Committee as the new President of BARCS. His three year term of office will be confirmed by the membership at the AGM 2019. I am confident that this announcement will be welcomed by all BARCS members. Many, if not all, members know Brian from his long record of achievements and activities in the silent flight field. He is especially known for his friendly cheerful manner, always at hand to help fellow modellers.


      Four years ago, Brian was awarded BARCS’ Eppler Trophy, in my opinion, the association’s the most prestigious award with a long list of distinguished aeromodellers such as Eppler himself.

      Graham James, BARCS President at that time, wrote the following citation: In the early years of BARCS, awarding was often a relatively straightforward decision as new construction methods, materials, wing sections, control methods and launch and landing requirements demanded continuous model development. Today, many of us have moved onto moulded ready builds and the skills of the true modeller are largely being lost.


      One person, Brian Austin, continues to lead the field in home design and build models. Responsible over the years for many familiar Open and 100s designs, his name is now better known in electric circles not only for his planes but also as a driving force behind competition rule progression. Names like Trilogy, Alacrity and more recently the Watts series of electric gliders, of which Watts New is the latest incarnation, will be familiar to us all. For many years, he has also been the responsible for running a very successful series of competitions in Essex.

      Although tempted by shiny plastic models too, he continues to fashion exquisitely beautiful soarers, built to standards that most of us can only
      aspire. They take the latest look and feel of moulded machines, but are built in more traditional ways. Brian pilots competition winning models.
        • Thanks
        • Like
      • 0 replies
    • Can F3J survive the treatment meant to save it
      What are the new rules?

      Two weeks ago the RC Soaring Technical Meeting in Lausanne took the bull by the horns and introduced new rules aimed at saving F3J glider contests from sliding off the world and continental championship schedules - the death of what for many soaring pilots is the most popular of silent flight competitions.

      Joe Wurts, the first F3J World Champion in 1998 at Upton-upon Severn, UK. Twenty years later with the latest F3J WC about to take place in Romania, many soarers are fearing that this could be the last.


      THE NEW RULES

      From next year pilots can use electric winches - either/or hand held winches - for launching their models. The models must have a maximum surface area of 150 dm2 and a minimum loading of at least 20 gm/dm2. There will be no dropped round in fly-offs, and no reflights for mid-air collisions after 60 seconds into the slot.

      CIAM, the world ruling body for this class is hoping that its new rules will halt the massive fall in numbers of F3J pilots wishing to compete, sixty per cent over the past five years and still falling, and restore its popularity.

      But among many F3J pilots, the bull is still shaking its horns. There has been an extraordinary shock reaction: hundreds of pilots from all over the world have reacted on social media, protesting, angry and forecasting the end of this class. Many pilots are concerned, ranging from previous finalists and champions to your typical enthusiast who enjoys travelling across country and continental boundaries to participate in their friendly sport. Only a few can see the logic and reasoning and are prepared to wait and see how the changes work in practice. More than a few want CIAM to think again!



       
      • 12 replies
    • Rule changes to halt terminal decline
      Uncle Sydney’ Gossip column returns

      FAI’s Aeromodelling Commission meets next month, 27/28 April 2018 in Lausanne, Switzerland. For F3J pilots the main topic on the agenda is how to halt the decline in silent flight contests. What does CIAM want to change?  What chance for these changes to save terminal decline?

      Winches to be allowed.

      If this proposal goes through the “launch of the model aircraft will be by hand held towline or winch.” Ever since 1998 when the first F3J world championships were held at Upton on Severn, pressure has been on CIAM to bring in winch launching. At numerous team managers’ meetings held by Jury President Bartovsky during World and European championships, arguments for and against have raged. Many countries do not have enough people to give one or two man tows, so they run their qualifying comps to local rules using electric winches. I guess more than half of countries do this. When they turn up at FAI championships, their pulleys and hand winches are brought out. In the UK perhaps we had one or two practice sessions at home before leaving.

      Certainly there is a difference between a regulation F3B winch and a two man tows. The best pilots still gain the most height either way. The big difference is what you need to carry on your travels, especially by airline. Winches and batteries are bulky and heavy. So far all votes have been to stick with hand towing.

      In CIAM agendas, any rule amendment is followed by its reasoning. 

      The winch proposal stems from Slovakia and they say: “The majority of pilots are older persons who are no longer physically capable of towing models. ( Uncle’s note: I have not seen anyone on crutches yet!) .....


       
      • 27 replies
    • by Sydney Lenssen, BARCS President and Gary Binnie, BARCS Chairman

      We and the BARCS executive committee wish all members, and indeed everyone who enjoys model flying and thermal soaring, a very happy Christmas, and also a very special year ahead in 2018. May all your achievements, higher scores and hopes be realised.

      Year 2017 has been a mixed year, probably for everybody. The biggest triumph by far has been the successful opening of BMFA’s National Flying Centre at Buckminster. BARCS can be very proud that it was the first group of aeromodellers to utilise the facilities on offer by organising a successful Radioglide 2017 at the end of May. 

      There is still a long way to go until BMFA realises all its ambitious plans for the NFC. Very sensibly, they are taking a careful financial route. Many members will not have even seen the site so far. Don’t hesitate. Many other members are in the band of volunteers, regularly making the Centre bigger and better. Offer to help if you can!

      One of the prime movers to establish the National Flying Centre is Chris Moynihan as chairman of the BMFA and also a member of the BARCS executive committee. Many years ago, it was Chris who tackled the difficult job of persuading BARCS to grow closer to the BMFA. He then went on to become chairman of the BMFA with his dedicated drive and skill at bringing together proponents and opponents. Very sadly, due to health problems, Chris has stepped down from both the BMFA chairman role and the BARCS committee. We shall all miss his wise counselling. 

      All the very best - and plenty of thermals - for 2018!

      Sydney Lenssen, BARCS President
       
      • 0 replies
    • Interglide F5J 2017 Report and Results
      This year’s Interglide over the weekend 24-25 June run by BARCS saw a necessary change from F3J to the electric launch format of F5J which proved to be very popular.

      Cracking flying site. Forty-seven pilots booked in. Prizes acquired, particular thanks going to UK KST agents, Flightech and C & M Rapid (Model Glasses) Ltd. for their generosity. The previous week saw fantastic weather. So what could possibly go wrong at Interglide 2017. Well, being the UK in June it’s no surprise, the weather changed for the week. Full report in the link above
      • 0 replies
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.